Catharine Mphee: American Idol: Who Sang It Better

So, is this now the new trend this season? Recycling themes! Haha. Well, since they reprise the theme from Season 5 this time. I've decided to have an Elvis Presley Face-Off - just like The Beatles Face-off a few days ago. This will be as interesting.

Featured Artist: Elvis Presley

In the strongest possible terms, the American Idol judges’ panel has insisted that “song choice, song choice, song choice” is the most critical decision a contestant can make. And week after week, most Idol hopefuls seem to get it completely wrong, and it could be due to the fact that they keep picking the same old overplayed songs.

Now, after numbing our ears year after year with the same predictable tunes, I think it's time to embrace that sad fact and just decide, which had the best version of the songs.

Videos and Poll after the jump!!