Now that this year's Top 5 has been announced. Let's look back and decide which season has the best Top 5.
Clarkson. Guarini. McKibbin. Gray. Helton.
Studdard. Aiken. Locke. Gracin. Trenyce.
Barrino. DeGarmo. Trias. London. Huff.
Underwood. Bice. Solomon. Federov. Savol.
Hicks. McPhee. Yamin. Daughtry. Bennett.
Sparks. Lewis. Doolittle. Jones. Richardson.
Cook. Archuleta. Mercado. Castro. White.
Allen. Lambert. Gokey. Iraheta. Giraud.
Dewyze. Bowersox. James. Kelly. Lynche.
Polls after the jump!!
